Confirmed Murder Victims of Serial Killer Richard Cottingham

Historical Chronology of Confirmed Murders 1967-1980

(top row)

1. 1967 Mary Ann Della Sala, Bergen County, NJ
 
2. 1967 Nancy Vogel, Bergen County, NJ

3. 1968 Diane Cusick, Nassau County, NY

4. 1968 Jacalyn "Jackie" Harp, Bergen County, NJ

5. 1969 Irene Blase, Bergen County, NJ

6. 1969 Denise Falasca, Bergen County, NJ

7. 1970 Lorraine McGraw, Rockland County, NY

8. 1972 Mary Beth Heinz, Nassau County, NY

9. 1972 Laverne Moye, Nassau County, NY

10. 1973 Sheila Heiman, Nassau County, NY

(bottom row)

11. 1973 Marita Rosada Nieves, Nassau County, NY

12. *1974 Lorraine Kelly, Bergen County, NJ

13. *1974 Mary Ann Pryor, Bergen County, NJ

14. mid-1970s currently undisclosed
  
15. 1977 Mary Ann Carr, Bergen County, NJ

16. *1979 Deedeh Goodarzi, New York County (Manhattan), NY

17. *1979 Unidentified female, New York County (Manhattan), NY

18. 1980 Valerie Ann Street, Bergen County, NJ

19. 1980 Marianne Jean Ghedini Reyner, New York County (Manhattan), NY

(* denotes double murders) 

Investigative Case Closure Chronology 1980-2024

Convictions in Trials 1981-1984

1.  1981 Valerie Ann Street, Bergen County, NJ (1980)
2.  1982 Mary Ann Carr, Bergen County, NJ (1977)
3. *1984 Unidentified female, New York County (Manhattan),NY (1979)
4. *1984 Deedeh Goodarzi, New York County (Manhattan),NY (1979)
5.  1984 Marianne Jean Ghedini Reyner, New York County (Manhattan),NY (1979)

Case Closures 2010-2017 by Detective Robert Anzilotti, BCPO, NJ

6.  2010 Nancy Vogel, Bergen County, NJ (1967)
7.  2014 Irene Blase, Bergen County, NJ (1969)
8.  2017 Denise Falasca, Bergen County, NJ (1969)
9.  2017 Jacalyn "Jackie" Harp, Bergen County, NJ (1968)

Case Closures 2021-2024 with assistance from Peter Vronsky and Jennifer Weiss

10. *2021 Lorraine Kelly Bergen County, NJ (1974)
11. *2021 Mary Ann Pryor Bergen County, NJ (1974)
12.  2022 Lorraine Montalvo McGraw, Rockland County, NY (1970)
13.  2022 Diane Cusick, Nassau County, NY (1968)
14.  2022 Mary Beth Heinz, Nassau County, NY, (1972)
15.  2022 Laverne Moye, Nassau County, NY (1972)
16.  2022 Sheila Heiman, Nassau County, NY (1973)
17.  2022 Marita Rosada Nieves, Nassau County, NY (1973)
18.  2022 Mary Ann Della Sala, Bergen County, NJ (1967)
19.  2024 Undisclosed, NY (mid-1970s)